Anthills, cobwebs and Internet Studies

I was recently involved in a brief email exchange with some fellow internet researchers over my New Media & Society 2008 article “Localizing the internet beyond communities and networks”. I thought it might be helpful if I posted here an analogy that may help future readers unfamiliar with social theory get to the gist of my argument and avoid misunderstandings.

In a nutshell, in the article I am suggesting that Internet Studies seems overly preoccupied -almost obsessed -  with two social life forms, namely ‘communities’ and ‘networks’, and relatively uninterested in the countless other forms studied by social scientists down the decades, such as gangs, cohorts, clans, age-sets, action-sets, coalitions, clubs, etc, etc. I call this the community/network paradigm, and I think it is akin to the hypothetical case of biologists studying a rich ecosystem being fixated on, say, anthills and cobwebs at the expense of all other natural designs to be found there.

See also Postill (forthcoming) ”Personal networks, social fields”

7 Responses to “Anthills, cobwebs and Internet Studies”

  1. community, the internet, and anthropology « another anthro blog Says:

    [...] but thanks for a nice essay discussing issues with the terminology and approaches. He brings up more discussion surrounding the essay on his blog. No Comments so far Leave a comment RSS feed for comments [...]

  2. John Postill Says:

    See also

    http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/content~content=a794424462~db=all?jumptype=alert&alerttype=new_issue_alert,email

  3. Is the Question ”why do anthropologists blog?” a Good Question to Think About? « Anthropology Sociology Online Magazine Says:

    [...] idea of what is meant in her/his work…A live example is the fascinating discussion between Dr.John Postill and Owen Wiltshire which I found in the latter blog in which Dr.Postill clarifies what he meant in [...]

  4. Personal networks, social fields « media/anthropology Says:

    [...] but without falling into the community/network trap lying at the heart of Internet Studies (Postill 2008). It draws from from recent ethnographic research on internet activism in a suburb of Kuala Lumpur [...]

  5. Fredrik Barth, practice theory and Danish teleworkers « media/anthropology Says:

    [...] event, the food and beverages consumed, the topics of conversation deemed appropriate, etc. (cf. Postill 2008 on ‘residential [...]

  6. iJump.co.nz » Helpful Links » links for 2008-07-25 Says:

    [...] Anthills, cobwebs and Internet Studies « media/anthropology Interesting thoughts! Do you know the difference between communities, gangs, cohorts, age-sets, action-sets and so on? (tags: community) [...]

  7. Suburban Internet Studies « media/anthropology Says:

    [...] sociality and banal activism provide useful entry points but are marred by their adherence to the community/network paradigm. The better known study was conducted by Keith Hampton in the Toronto suburb of ‘Netville’ (a [...]

Leave a Reply